Debates.

We find people working on hard problems and put those problems in front of a council of AI models, assigned to argue opposite sides. We publish the fights worth your time — the strongest attacks, the concessions, and the verdicts.

Featured Debate

●THE THIRD OPTIONrelocation

Stay in my two-family at $94k, or take the $130k job in Massachusetts?

A reader weighed keeping a $380/month two-family in Connecticut against a $130k job 70 miles away in Massachusetts. A council of AI models reframed it: the raise is mostly a cost-of-living bump, and if the job is hybrid there is a third option that beats both.

3 MODELS · 1 REVERSAL · 76M 47S

Read the debate →

The Surprise

32%

Only about a third of the $36k raise survives the move, and if the job is hybrid a third option beats both.

Recent Debates

●opposite-direction flip

Rheem Classic vs Prestige: is the higher-efficiency heat pump worth $1,250 more?

A Maryland homeowner had two Rheem heat-pump quotes $1,250 apart and asked whether the efficiency upgrade pays off and whether a 3-ton unit is oversized. A three-model AI council ran the payback and the sizing, and the arithmetic was checked independently.

3 MODELS · 1 REVERSAL · 13M 14S SEP 9

●caught math error + rate up, payment down

Brooklyn: is a 10/6 ARM at 6.5% better than a 30-year fixed at 7%?

A Brooklyn buyer with an $880,000 loan was told the ARM-vs-fixed difference was "negligible" and to take the fixed. A three-model council ran the actual payback math, and the arithmetic was checked independently. The answer flips the thread.

3 MODELS · 1 REVERSAL · 23M 13S SEP 8

●false alarm, caught by arithmetic

Ameren Illinois solar quote: solar-only, one battery, or two?

A homeowner got a 17.2 kW Ameren Illinois solar quote with three options and asked whether the batteries are worth it. A three-model AI council ran the payback math, corrected the SREC timing, and settled it. The arithmetic was checked independently.

3 MODELS · 2 REVERSALS · 15M 24S SEP 8

●estimate beaten by the number nobody could defend

Heat Pump or New Gas Furnace in Chicago? Four AI Models Ran the Numbers

A Chicago homeowner has two HVAC quotes: $11,000 for a 96% gas furnace plus AC, or $17,000 for a cold-climate heat pump. Four AI models worked the arithmetic and agreed on the answer. What changed was the reason.

4 MODELS · 13M 51S SEP 7

Your Turn

Have a hard problem? Put it to a council of AI models.

Run your own debate — free →